What Do We Know? Not as Much as We Think.

For the past two weeks, the airwaves and internet have been buzzing over the deaths of Michael Jackson and now Steve McNair. Just as with the death of Princess Diana, commentators have marveled at the extent of the public emotional outpouring over complete strangers. Celebrity gives the impression of familiarity, they tell us.

For those of us in Nashville, the death of McNair seems to have hit especially hard. People on the screen as well as the average person on the street have done all sorts of verbal gymnastics to try to maintain the McNair-as-hero image in spite of the very sobering facts surrounding his last months. Perhaps part of it is due to the coupling of words “sports” and “hero.” We do this pairing way too easily in American society in spite of the fact that we have more than enough evidence by now to realize that high-level, high-paying sports are just as likely to bring out the meaner part of human nature as they do the heroic and noble. Secondly, we seem to have a hard time accepting that people can be both mean and noble. It reminds me of a friend of mine who had an affair. She once said to me despondently, “I still want to be Gandhi, but people only think of me now in terms of this one mistake.” But in our sound-bite culture, we often find it hard to take the full measure of a person.

But perhaps the real lesson to be learned here is the reminder that, despite the number of times we see celebrities on television and online, despite the number of interviews they give, and despite the number of articles we read about them, we don’t know them. Most celebrities spend a great deal of money to hire people to ensure that the public image is the only one we see. We need to take a step back and remind ourselves that the fact that someone is cheerful in an interview doesn’t tell us much about the real person. (In fact, it only tells us that he/she knows how to give a good interview.)

Recently, I read an article by two philosophy professors who said that instructors of critical thinking have traditionally spent their time on critically reading texts, which, of course, is important. Still, for most people now, the main mode of garnering information is not through text. People need to know how to critically evaluate what they see on the screen as well as what they see on the page.

Despite the gossip and publicity, to me, it all comes down to this. Three lives are lost, and families are grieving. Let us hope that we the public will give them the space to mourn in private.

4 thoughts on “What Do We Know? Not as Much as We Think.

  1. ‘people can be both mean and noble.’ I like that. Or sleazy and completely aboveboard. Or violent and peaceful, arrogant and humble, generous and miserly, clueless and insightful, or any number of other contradictions merged into one individual. And not just mood swings over time, but co-existing at one time. Whoever heard of being both jolly and a librarian, after all? Such we are, as humans; perhaps the defining characteristic of our species in not an opposable thumb and tool use, but co-existing contradiction. Somebody at a party on the 4th of July raved about what a marvelous man McNair was for his help with the Dismas House organization. Verily, he was not Gandhi, but even Gandhi beat his wife for refusing chamber pot duty.

  2. Thanks, Faye. We are, each of us, more than any one decision that we make or action that we take. For me, the death of Michael Jackson causes me to reflect on my own life as well as his (we are close in age). He certainly is part of the “sound track” of my memories. I’d like to try to see if I could watch the Thriller video enough to tire of it…I don’t think its possible!


    1. I think “Thriller” is the all time best video ever made.

      And I think your statement is a very true one: We are more than any one decision we have made. One of McNair’s teammates said that he too had made mistakes, but unlike McNair, he still had time to fix them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s